This is a translation of the original article in Portuguese. Read the original (Português).
The defense of banker Daniel Vorcaro, who has been jailed since March, filed a writ of mandamus with Brazil’s Supreme Federal Court (STF) against a decision by the Court’s president, Edson Fachin, to transfer Operation Compliance Zero to the Presidency. The operation is linked to the Banco Master case. This is according to the newspapers Diário de Notícias and Folha de S.Paulo.
According to the lawyers, the case already had a rapporteur, Justice André Mendonça, and the court’s case-distribution rules must be followed. They ask that the case be returned to him. Because the writ of mandamus is a new action, its rapporteur will be chosen by lottery, according to Diário de Notícias.
The defense also argues that the STF’s internal rules do not allow the Presidency to take over the case, even temporarily. For that reason, it asks Justice Gilmar Mendes to review the appeal until the case is redistributed, according to Folha.
At stake is who will lead the investigations into the bank, which was liquidated and left losses for investors. A dispute over the rapporteur role could affect the pace of decisions and the next steps of the inquiry.
In the STF, cases are generally distributed by lottery among justices, and whoever receives a case becomes its rapporteur, responsible for overseeing it and bringing it to trial. Vorcaro’s defense claims that this rule was disregarded in this instance. If the rapporteur role changes hands, the new justice will have to familiarize themselves with the case, which could alter how decisions move forward. The responsible bodies have yet to detail how the proceedings will be handled.
The debate over the Master case goes beyond the courts. One year after the bank’s liquidation, according to Folha, market specialists are calling for changes in oversight, in the structure of investment funds and in the distribution of CDBs (bank certificates of deposit), as well as more resources and technology for the CVM (Brazil’s securities regulator) and the Central Bank.
The discussion also includes revising the R$ 250,000 limit guaranteed by the Credit Guarantee Fund (FGC) and approving PLP 281/2019, a bill awaiting a vote in the Chamber of Deputies.
Reporting from Diário de Notícias (p. 3, nacional), Folha de SP (p. 13, Brasília/DF), Folha de SP (p. 26, São Paulo/SP).
Deixe um comentário