This is a translation of the original article in Portuguese. Read the original (Português).
Seven in every ten federal services offer no in-person service at any stage. That is what an audit by Brazil’s Federal Audit Court (TCU), released on November 12, shows. The audit examined 5,616 services and concluded that 72% of them depend entirely on digital channels, according to the newspaper Diário do Pará (a Brazilian newspaper).
The survey points to who suffers most: elderly people, people with disabilities, people with low levels of schooling, and residents of rural areas and of the North Region face more obstacles in getting access to what the government offers.
In Congress, a bill is trying to address the problem. The Science and Technology Committee of the Senate approved a substitute to PL 1,159/2026, authored by Senator Jader Barbalho, which guarantees in-person service and human support for the elderly in essential services.
The text is not yet law. The proposal now goes to the Senate’s Human Rights Committee. If it is approved and signed into law, the rules will take effect 180 days after publication. The responsible agencies must still detail how the service will be organized in practice.
The issue touches the daily routine of millions of families. Benefits, retirement and documents increasingly depend on apps and websites, and those without digital access, or who do not know how to use it, risk losing rights that are already theirs. For an elderly person living in an inland city in the North, where access to the internet and to agencies tends to be harder, the barrier is likely to be greater than for someone living in a Southeastern capital, with more service options nearby.
The TCU figure shows the scale of the challenge: if most federal services have no in-person stage at all, the guarantee in the bill, limited to the elderly in essential services, would reach only part of those facing difficulties. People with disabilities and with low schooling, also mentioned in the audit, are not the focus of the text approved in committee, as described by Diário do Pará.
While the law is not in force, elderly people who need in-person service depend on the channels that still exist in each service. The bill continues in the Human Rights Committee, the next stage of the proposal.
Reporting from Diário do Pará (p. 7, Brasília/DF: Comissão do Senado aprova atendimento presencial a idosos), Diário do Pará (p. 7, nacional: TCU aponta falhas digitais que dificultam acesso a serviços federais).
Deixe um comentário