This is a translation of the original article in Portuguese. Read the original (Português).
Eight in every ten consumers with overdue bills took on new debt to pay off another in the past year. That is what a survey by CNDL and SPC Brasil shows, published by the newspaper Extra, which interviewed 609 people in all state capitals with payments more than three months late.
According to the survey, 81% of respondents did this in the last 12 months. Among them, 25% repeat the behavior every month, which points to a difficult cycle to break.
The cost of credit helps explain the squeeze. In September, the overdraft facility carried an average interest rate of 139% a year, and personal credit loans 111% a year. Credit card revolving interest reached 15.18% a month in August, equivalent to about 444.9% a year. In this scenario, swapping one debt for another without comparing rates can increase the amount owed in a short time.
Experts interviewed by Extra note that payroll-deducted loans, taken out with payments deducted directly from a paycheck or benefit, usually carry much lower interest than revolving credit and overdraft facilities. Credit portability, which allows moving a debt to another institution with a better rate, also appears among the recommendations.
Another option is the Superindebtedness Law. It allows renegotiating consumer debts over up to five years, while preserving what is known as the mínimo existencial, a minimum living allowance set at R$ 600, an amount that cannot be committed to paying debts. Renegotiation brings all creditors together, instead of separate agreements.
Extra told the story of a 56-year-old woman retired due to disability, with an income of R$ 3,000. She accumulated loans and turned to the law to renegotiate what she owed. For people in similar situations, assistance is offered by Procon Carioca, Procon-RJ and the Public Defender’s Office.
The backdrop is the Selic rate at 13.75%, which keeps credit expensive for people who work and depend on loans to get through the month. With interest at this level, the difference between one type of credit and another weighs heavily on the budget: credit card revolving interest costs several times more than payroll-deducted loans.
In practice, the roadmap recommended by experts is to list all debts, compare rates, prioritize replacing the most expensive ones with cheaper lines and, if payments are already out of control, seek a consumer protection agency to negotiate with all creditors at once.
Reporting from Extra (Aposentada recorre à Lei do Superendividamento, p. 11 (Rio de Janeiro/RJ)), Extra (Oito em cada dez inadimplentes contraem nova dívida para pagar outra, p. 10), Extra (Taxas do cheque especial e do rotativo do cartão chegam a centenas por cento ao ano, p. 10).
Deixe um comentário