This is a translation of the original article in Portuguese. Read the original (Português).
The finance secretary of São Paulo, Samuel Kinoshita, fired auditor Marcelo de Almeida Gouveia, who served as ombudsman of the state’s Tax Enforcement Office from 2018 to 2022. The information comes from the Brazilian newspaper A Tribuna de Santos.
Gouveia was caught up in Operation Ícaro, which investigates suspected kickback schemes worth billions of reais within the state’s tax enforcement division. The auditor’s defense said it will appeal the dismissal.
This is the second ombudsman dismissed in a span of seven months. The repetition is striking because the Ombudsman’s Office is the body responsible for monitoring the conduct of the tax inspectors themselves, in other words, for overseeing those who oversee tax collection.
What Is at Stake for Taxpayers
When tax auditors are suspected of trading in decisions, the damage does not stop at the state’s coffers. Companies that follow the rules can be harmed by competitors who pay less tax improperly, and the cost of lower revenue tends to fall on those who pay on time. There is also an effect on trust: citizens and business owners begin to doubt the impartiality of assessments, fines and settlements.
The dismissal is an administrative measure and does not close the Operation Ícaro investigation. The appeal announced by the defense is expected to challenge the secretary’s decision, and the case remains under investigation.
The departure of two ombudsmen in seven months puts a spotlight on the internal control mechanisms of the São Paulo State Finance Department. The body that should identify misconduct now finds itself among the targets of the suspicions, which increases pressure for transparency over how the state oversees its own tax inspectors.
Reporting from A Tribuna de Santos (p. 15, São Paulo/SP).
Deixe um comentário