This is a translation of the original article in Portuguese. Read the original (Português).
Data from the federal government itself show that the Lula administration used legal secrecy as the justification in 34.3% of denied information requests between January 2023 and November 16, 2026. Under the Bolsonaro government, the rate was 22.9%. The figures were published by the newspaper O Estado de S. Paulo, one of Brazil’s largest dailies.
The comparison comes as Brazil’s Access to Information Law (LAI) marks its 15th anniversary. The law guarantees anyone the right to request data and documents from public bodies, without having to explain why they want the information.
The survey covers only denied requests, not the total. According to the Office of the Comptroller General (CGU), 8 in every 10 requests made to the government are granted. In other words, most requests receive a response, but among the refusals, secrecy provided for by law now appears more often than under the previous administration.
What this means for citizens: those who need public documents to demand services, monitor contracts or understand government decisions depend on clear answers. When a refusal is based on claimed secrecy, access to information becomes more restricted, and an appeal becomes the way to challenge the denial.
In practice, requests can be made online, through the access-to-information channels of federal agencies, by stating what one wants to know and providing a means of contact for the reply. The agency is obliged to respond, either granting or denying the request with a legal justification. If a request is denied, it is possible to appeal.
Reporting from O Estado de S. Paulo (p. 8, Brasília/DF: Gestão Lula supera a de Bolsonaro no uso de sigilo para negar documentos).
Deixe um comentário