This is a translation of the original article in Portuguese. Read the original (Português).
Brazil’s Prosecutor General, Paulo Gonet, has argued that the Supreme Federal Court (STF) should reject the second request for criminal review filed by the defense of Jair Bolsonaro. The former president was sentenced to 27 years and 3 months in prison for attempting a coup d’état. The position was published by the Brazilian newspaper O Fluminense.
Gonet’s central argument is that the lawyers have not brought new evidence into the case. This is the point that carries the most weight in the analysis, since a criminal review is not meant to relitigate what has already been judged, but to correct convictions in specific situations, such as the discovery of elements that did not exist in the case file.
A criminal review is the mechanism that allows a request for a court to revisit a conviction that has become final. For that reason, the absence of new facts tends to be the main obstacle for anyone trying to reopen a case at this stage.
The rapporteur for the request is Justice Kassio Nunes Marques. It falls to him to oversee the analysis and release the case for judgment. According to the newspaper, the case should be taken to the full STF bench, that is, to a joint decision by the justices, and not only to an individual ruling.
The opinion of the Attorney General’s Office (Procuradoria-Geral da República) is not binding. It is a submission that the justices consider, but that does not require them to follow the same path. The final decision will rest with the Supreme Court.
The outcome matters well beyond the case itself. If the conviction could be reopened, the result would reverberate in the 2026 political contest and in the relationship between the branches of government. If the request is rejected, the conviction stands as it is.
The STF has yet to set when the case will be placed on the plenary agenda.
Reporting from O Fluminense (p. 9, Brasília/DF).
Deixe um comentário