This is a translation of the original article in Portuguese. Read the original (Português).
Brazil spends R$ 331 billion a year on eight cash-transfer programs, the equivalent of 2.6% of GDP, double what it spent in 2012. Even so, almost 10 million people still live in extreme poverty, at a time when unemployment is at the lowest level in the historical series. This paradox is the starting point for the Programa de Proteção e Mobilidade Social (Promob), a proposal released this week by the Centro de Debate de Políticas Públicas (CDPP), a Brazilian public policy think tank.
The study is signed by three economists: Vinícius Botelho, former secretary at the Ministry of Social Development; Fernando Veloso, research director at the Instituto Mobilidade e Desenvolvimento Social (Imds); and Marcos Mendes, researcher at Insper. Their conclusion fits in a single sentence from the document itself: the problem is the architecture of the programs, not the budget.
What the Promob proposes
The proposal merges Bolsa Família, the Benefício de Prestação Continuada (BPC), the abono salarial wage bonus, Pé-de-Meia, seguro-defeso fishing unemployment insurance, Gás do Povo, salário-família family allowance and auxílio-inclusão into three programs, according to the summary published by the CDPP.
The first is the Benefício de Renda Mínima, a minimum income benefit. It tops up family income to a threshold that depends on who lives in the household: at 2025 values, R$ 1,540 per elderly person or person with a disability, R$ 420 per child up to age 6, and R$ 280 per person of other ages. In practice, no one would fall below the extreme poverty line.
The second is the Poupança Seguro Família, a family savings insurance account. For those who receive the minimum income, the government deposits into an account the equivalent of 30% of declared labor income, invested in Treasury bonds. The money can be withdrawn when income falls, and it works as insurance for people with informal or unstable work. The combination of the two addresses what the authors call a bad exit problem: today, earning R$ 100 more in wages can cost more than R$ 100 in benefits. Under the Promob, each additional real of labor income reduces the total received by only R$ 0.50. Working more always pays off.
The third is the Programa Mais Educação, a savings account opened for each student from a served family starting in elementary school, released only after completing high school. According to the CDPP, the accumulated amount exceeds R$ 10,000 before high school. The program also foresees identifying talented young people, offering mentoring and providing information about careers.
Finally, there are measures to improve the Cadastro Único, the federal registry of low-income families, such as a single concept of family and income for all programs, cross-checking of income, consumption and asset data, and electronic updating of information.
The simulation numbers
Using data from the 2025 Pnad Contínua household survey, the authors calculate that the Promob would eliminate 100% of extreme poverty, measured by the international line of US$ 3 per day. The number of people below US$ 4.20 per day would fall by 24%, and the number of poor people with no benefits at all would fall by 86%. The program would serve 32.5 million families without increasing total spending, according to the CDPP.
The study itself makes an important caveat: the result depends on a registry that actually finds those who need help. Fixing registry problems alone would already reduce extreme poverty by 38%, according to the authors. In other words, part of the gain would come from making what already exists work better.
The most sensitive point: the BPC
The BPC pays a minimum wage to low-income elderly people and people with disabilities and cost R$ 116.6 billion in 2025. Under the proposal, it would stop accepting new beneficiaries, and the R$ 1,540 value per elderly person or person with a disability in the minimum income was calculated precisely to soften this switch. Current recipients would not lose out: during the transition, existing benefits would be frozen or adjusted for inflation, and the family would always receive the option of the higher amount, according to the study’s text.
This is where the debate should heat up. The BPC is provided for in the Constitution, which is why the proposal includes, besides a bill, a constitutional amendment.
An idea that keeps coming back
The Promob is the third version of the same idea. In 2020, the same three economists, together with two other authors, published through the CDPP the Programa de Responsabilidade Social, which already used the names Benefício de Renda Mínima, Poupança Seguro Família and Mais Educação. It was much smaller: it merged four programs, with about R$ 57 billion.
The proposal became bill 5,343/2020, the Lei de Responsabilidade Social (Social Responsibility Law), introduced in December 2020 by then-senator Tasso Jereissati, according to the Senate. The text added poverty reduction targets, received a report from then-senator Simone Tebet and was shelved at the end of the legislative term in December 2022. The 2026 version is about six times larger and includes, for the first time, the BPC and Pé-de-Meia.
Other voices in the same debate
The defense of unifying benefits does not come from one side only. In 2019, researchers Sergei Soares, Letícia Bartholo and Rafael Osorio, from the Instituto de Pesquisa Econômica Aplicada (Ipea), the federal government’s applied economic research institute, proposed merging Bolsa Família, the wage bonus, family allowance and the income tax deduction per child into a universal benefit per child, combined with a benefit against extreme poverty. According to the authors, the effect on poverty and inequality would double, at the same cost.
Today director of Social Studies and Policies at Ipea, Bartholo told the newspaper Folha de S.Paulo that Bolsa Família should have a floor per person rather than per family. In 2023, the World Bank had already suggested the same change, according to the newspaper O Liberal. The per-family floor, which was R$ 600 and rose to R$ 691 with the September adjustment, pays the same amount to someone living alone and to a household with several people. According to the authors of the Promob, cited by the newspaper O Globo, the share of one-person families in Bolsa Família reached 27% in 2022, compared with 15% before.
Official data show why these programs matter. According to the IBGE’s Síntese de Indicadores Sociais (Social Indicators Synthesis), released by Agência Gov, extreme poverty stood at 3.5% of the population in 2024 and would be 10% without social benefits. Poverty would be 28.7%, not 23.1%.
What the world has tried
United Kingdom. The closest example to the Promob is Universal Credit, created in 2012, which replaced six benefits with a single one. The benefit phases out gradually as earnings rise, at a rate that fell from 65% to 55% in 2021. The migration, however, dragged on for more than a decade, and the five-week wait for the first payment became the main criticism.
Mexico. Progresa, launched in 1997 and later renamed Oportunidades and Prospera, inspired Bolsa Família and was one of the most evaluated programs in the world, with gains in school enrollment and child health. In 2019, the government ended it and transferred its education component to scholarships, according to the magazine Expansión.
Chile. The Ingreso Ético Familiar, from 2012, combines a base income with bonuses for meeting obligations and achievements, and a subsidy that pays women part of their salary for four years after they get formal employment.
United States. The Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC), created in 1975, is the largest work incentive policy for low-income families. In 2024, about 24 million workers received around US$ 70 billion, according to the American tax authority, the IRS.
Kenya and Finland. In Kenya, a study published in the journal Econometrica with the organization GiveDirectly showed that transfers of about US$ 1,000 to more than 10,000 families boosted the local economy, with a multiplier effect of 2.5 and almost no inflation. In Finland, a basic income paid to 2,000 unemployed people between 2017 and 2018 slightly increased employment but reduced stress and increased participants’ confidence.
China. In 2021, the Chinese government declared it had lifted 98.99 million people out of rural extreme poverty over eight years, using its own national line, according to the Al Jazeera network.
What remains open
The CDPP has started talks to present the study to members of the government, according to the newspaper O Globo, but the government has not yet commented on the proposal. The study itself warns that, in an economic crisis, the current system would be even more fragile, precisely when more families would need it.
The official goal of ending extreme poverty is set for the period from 2028 to 2030. The Promob shows that the money exists. The question is whether there is political will to change programs that together reach tens of millions of families, some of them protected by the Constitution.
Reporting from CDPP (Promob: página do estudo), CDPP (Promob: resumo), CDPP (Promob: texto principal), Folha de S.Paulo (via O Fio), O Globo (via CDPP), Valor (via CDPP), Brasil 247, CDPP (Programa de Responsabilidade Social (2020)), Senado Federal (PL 5.343/2020), Blog do Ibre (FGV), Ipea (Texto para Discussão 2505), O Liberal (Banco Mundial), Mercado & Consumo (reajuste do Bolsa Família), Agência Gov (IBGE, Síntese de Indicadores Sociais), Wikipedia (Universal Credit), Wikipedia (Prospera), Expansión, Revista de Administração Pública (Chile), IRS (EITC), Econometrica (Quênia), Basic Income Earth Network (Finlândia), Al Jazeera (China).
Deixe um comentário