This is a translation of the original article in Portuguese. Read the original (Português).
The technical staff of Brazil’s Federal Court of Audits (TCU) found signs of irregularities in the radio and television address by President Lula aired on the 8th, according to the Brazilian newspaper O Sul. The report cites possible violations, such as the use of images from the election campaign, symbols of the Workers’ Party (PT), and praise for the electoral comeback.
The audit is the first step in a process that could end in sanctions. Before that, the Public Prosecutor’s Office at the court (Ministério Público de Contas) and the court’s justices still have to review the case. So far, there is no decision on any penalty.
The TCU also recommended that the Office of Social Communication of the Presidency (Secom) be asked about the partisan content of the broadcast. The Planalto Palace has not commented on the report.
The complaint that led the court to examine the address was filed by lawmakers from the Novo party.
What is at stake
Nationwide radio and TV addresses use airtime paid for with public funds and, for that reason, are expected to be institutional in nature: informing the public about government actions, programs, and decisions. Party or electoral advertising follows a different logic, with its own rules and airtime, and seeks to promote a political group or a candidate.
It is this boundary that the TCU report puts under debate by pointing to campaign images and party symbols in an official speech. The outcome could serve as a reference for government communication in periods close to elections.
What could happen next
With the technical report complete, the case moves to the opinion of the Public Prosecutor’s Office at the court and then to a ruling by the justices. It is up to them to decide whether there was an irregularity and, if so, whether there will be a sanction and of what kind. Secom may be called on to clarify the content of the broadcast.
The Planalto has not yet presented its position. When the government responds, its defense argument should be taken into account in the court’s analysis.
Reporting from O Sul (p. 19, caderno nacional: "TCU vê indícios de irregularidades em pronunciamento de Lula na TV").
Deixe um comentário